3/3/14

Reading 3 - Lauren Owensby

The Selfish Gene by Richard Dawkins provides an interesting look at lasting cultural elements in history by characterizing them as memes in comparison to genes. I was surprised by the turn it took at the end; it reminded me of the different grounds for ethical arguments. I was expecting a more detailed explanation of what keeps such memes in circulation that would reflect more on the modern meaning of the word "meme"; i.e. resonance with community values, encapsulation of a mindset, etc. The lines about "disinterested altruism" threw me off, because it is assumed that all human actions gravitate towards selfishness (survival of the individual) rather than working within a community to ensure mutual survival of everyone in that community.

I think memes are starting to deteriorate in lifespan because most of our needs in modern society have been met. There is nothing forcing us to fear hell and fire, there is no perceived "need" for an afterlife because our current life is not overwhelmingly miserable. In addition, the internet facilitates the development of new memes that reflect on the people who carry them at each moment in time, replacing others that we consider less applicable. Yet I feel that the existence and prevalence of these memes fail to be accurate reflections of who we are. Take humor, for instance. Most jokes are harmful or derogatory in nature, yet are made to help face that division and ease the tension associated with it. They can help spread awareness, inspire exploration, and give others a basis for addressing similar issues.

Reading 3 - Franki Abraham


Y’know, I had always wondered where the term “meme” had come from. Unlike the word “blog” that was derived from a fast-paced pronunciation of “web log”, the term “meme” seemed to have no apparent root or origin. And then this article is presented to me and I come to learn that meme has the deepest roots of all. Not even just a root but a root that entangles and grows along side genes and Darwinism? Whaaaat?

This article intrigued me to the fullest extent. When as before a “meme” was just a popular web based picture, it has now been explained to me as much more.

Here are the several definitions of meme that I have found during succeeding research after this article. 

1 : an idea, belief or belief system, or pattern of behavior that spreads throughout a culture either vertically by cultural inheritance (as by parents to children) or horizontally by cultural acquisition (as by peers, information media, and entertainment media)

2 : a pervasive thought or thought pattern that replicates itself via cultural means; a parasitic code, a virus of the mind especially contagious to children and the impressionable

3 : the fundamental unit of information, analogous to the gene in emerging evolutionary theory of culture
- meme pool (n.) : all memes of a culture or individual
- memetic (adj.) : relating to memes
- memetics (n.) : the study of memes

4 : in blogspeak, an idea that is spread from blog to blog

5 : an internet information generator, especially of random or “content-less” information

(Etymology : meme : derived from the Greek mimëma, 'something imitated', by Richard Dawkins in 1976)

The pure fact that a meme can grow and evolve along side the human race genetically is mind-boggling. Cultural growth is so much like biological and it is always shifting and adapting to new challenges and ideas.


Ahhh, this article was so cool! Mind was blown.

Reading 3 - Frank Hu

Genes and memes, really? I can understand where the author is coming from. Like genes, memes have high fecundity and are replicable. They do have many similarities, and the meme is infinitely more fertile than genes. With that said, I really can't believe the author compared the two.

Look at how long genes have been around. Memes in comparison have existed for less than 0.0001% of the time. Even the meme of god the author uses has not been around long. The internet age has enabled the creation of easily digestible, valuable content. However, most of it is easily forgotten and far less valuable than genes. Putting them on the same level exalts memes to some higher level that it does not deserve. Despite sharing many similarities, memes are bacteria (short run resistant but long run forgettable) compared to genes. Memes may have high fecundity but the life time of an entire type is extremely short.

3/2/14

Reading 3-Lauren Arnold

After reading chapter eleven from the novel The Selfish Gene, I was very excited to hear that someone else did not think that our evolution came down to just conventional rules of biology. Obviously, Darwin was correct in many ideas behind evolution in terms of physical evolution within natural selection. But after taking many more Communications courses and studying identity within both my Communications and Art classes, I have come to realize that we evolve as individuals through culture as well.

For one, I have noticed that there has been evolutions of individuals in the professional working world. Who surpasses individuals in what they do? Who received the best job? It is often the people who carry themselves confidently and speak with the most confidence. It is the individuals who embody what they preach to their team. These are the strong leaders.

 But, over time, I have come to recognize that a lot of the kinds of people who do extremely well in the work world also have certain materialistic items or attributes that enable them to reach high levels of success. For instance, cell phones. Over the past ten years, the individuals who thrive in what they are doing often times are the individuals who are the most "connected" in our world with technology. If you look at the top CEOs of a business, who typically has the newest and best iPhone or new smart phone within the company? More times than not, it is the business leader versus those who work under him within the corporation. Nice materials= respect for the individual. But just as chapter eleven explains, "the change must be progressive" and it must prove that "modern science is better than ancient." This is extremely important to take note on. When referring to both memes and genes, those individuals who surpass the lives of others in their success; are those who have both genes and/or memes that are better adapted in the situational circumstances.

Take for instance, the Greek System at DePauw. Those who thrive the most within many of these systems are able bodied, intelligent, and positive people to be around. These attributes are understood as most likely genes that exceeded expectations. However, we can also look at memes within this situation. What if it is not solely that the individual is able bodied, intelligent, and positive based on their genes- what if these are all based on choices that the individual has made in order to thrive this much? Then it comes down to the idea of memes of culture or replications of what is successful in culture. The Greek System could arguably almost be compared to what the passage states as, "tribal religion" or "a way to solidify group identity." This is exactly what I see within the separate houses on campus. Just as the chapter states, the separate "kin are selected and selection in favor of reciprocal altruism has acted on human genes to produce many of our psychological attributes and tendencies." This description could be argued as ways that our system endorses certain behaviors such as rituals that ostracize others, events that promote under aged drinking, as well as extremely sexist views coming from some houses. At some point, these ideas were the best ways to survive survival of the fittest. But over time, I think that individuals will start to defy these traditions and fight for something more. In the same way that religion is described on page 197, the way to enforce religion is to have present the "threat of hell fire" as individuals think that they will "endure ghostly torments if they do not obey the rules."

This type of conventional thinking of right vs wrong answer, or black versus white is also very much endorsed in other forms of our culture. Many of them do evolve around the memes that are representative of everyday life through cultures of technology, materialistic symbols- clothes, and ideas practiced.

I found this article to be extremely interesting in the portion where it describes the parts of ourselves that we leave behind in terms of memes in literacy and cultural forms. Because when all of the genes have not been carried over, what is left behind of ourselves are our ideas. This is something very encouraging to hear as an artist. A quote that I have discussed with some of my art friends for instance is, "But if you contribute to the world's culture, good idea, compose a tune, invent a sparkling tune, write a poem, it may live on, in fact, long after genes have dissolved in the common pool." Another favorite quote is, "who cares if Socrates has a gene alive here today" "the memes complexes he has left behind are still here" (199).

This is incredible, and I think as an artist this is something we all crave for- a form of ourselves to be remembered and cherished. A portion of ourselves to be impermanent and live on forever.

Reading 3 - Truc Le

a meme's process
(source)

In “Memes: The New Replicators”, Richard Dawkins (2006, pp. 189-201) uses the concepts of genes to explain those of memes and examines the importance as well as the affects of memes in human cultures. I feel that anything, especially any work of art, as long as it is simple and appealing to the mind (for example, catchy tunes or funny GIFs), has the potential to go viral and become memes. In my opinion, straightforward ideas and art pieces can easily become memes because people can interpret a simple piece in many different ways that suit their existing interests. Because it is easier for people to create their own interpretations out of simple things, people are more likely to favor and remember these things. For example, PSY’s Gangnam Style was once a huge meme on the internet. Having memorable tunes and funny short horse dances, Gangnam Style easily caught the public attention and went viral on the internet. Although PSY stated that this song’s message is to mock the Gangnam district people’s extravagant lifestyles, the internet community extracted different meanings from the song (such as the Gangnam style doomsday prophecy) and spread these fan-made versions, thus maintaining the song’s popularity for months. Simplicity worked for Gangnam Style and numerous other memes. Therefore, I think the artists should keep simplicity in mind when creating arts if they want their work to be ‘spreadable’.


At the end of the essay, Dawkins expressed his fear of the uncontrollability of memes and his hope for human’s alertness when spreading memes. I sympathize with Dawkins only if the meme being examined is an indoctrination or a conservative idea that people are forced to learn. However, if it is a short-duration meme such as a catchy tune, a hilarious image, or even an addictive game like Flappy Bird, I do not think that these memes are going to cause any negative long-term consequences. Although it can be annoying to encounter these memes so many times, I feel that it is natural and sometimes necessary for humans to share their memes. Having seen that each person can have his or her own interpretations of memes, I think that through spreading memes, a person can be expressing their thinkings and characteristics as well. Therefore, I think that sharing memes is a social need, and because memes pass by, they should not be considered as threats to human minds.

3/1/14

Reading 3 - Khoi

The Selfish Gene by Richard Dawkins provides an interesting explanation of human behavior and of the fundamental ideas of Darwin's Evolution theory.  It turns out that gene - the smallest genetic unit - preserves the patterns of information over time and is potentially, albeit with intention or nit, the answer to most questions concerning the current world's orders.  In chapter 11, Dawkins introduces a new idea of meme, which, he argues, bears quite substantial resemblance to gene.  Meme however is a more advanced edition and although possessing similar fundamental characters of gene such as fecundity, longevity, exactness in copying and so on, not necessarily "subservient" to gene's behavior.

The most interesting argument about gene and meme from the chapter is the power of these elements to orchestrate a world full of selfish individuals.  If gene achieves such order by natural selection that allows only selfish individuals to reappear in the gene pools, meme is argued to deploy the same method.  In a limited time and space of human brains, only those meme who is capable of capturing human attention continues to flourish in the future.  This opens an interesting implication about arts.  Most of artworks, in order to be successful, need not only innovation and aesthetic pleasing quality but also the ability to be remembered and referred to over an as long as possible time period.  This ability is achieved either via presentation or the idea inherited in the art or some other means.  

However, as human always possess certain qualities that lying beyond the rules of the selfishness such as the "foreseeability", arts should also seek for some other meanings and qualities beyond those that aim for everlasting popularity.  In fact, it is usually the case that artworks that strive for popularity fall into mediocrity while those idiosyncratic ones flourish in a much unexpected pattern

Reading 3 - Panpan Deng

 

In the article Memes: The New Replicators, the author presented a relatively new analogy between "scientific progress and genetic evolution by natural selection." (Dawkins, Richard) As an enthusiastic Darwinian himself, Richard believed that the survival of replicating entities such as human genes has much similarity from the survival of meme which is a term made by Richard himself. "Meme" is a noun that "conveys the idea of a unit of cultural transmission, or a unit of imitation."(Dawkins) I find this analogy very interesting for the reason that since I was a kid, I liked to make the "idea" in people's mind as a seed. Once it was in your mind, it glow and glow until its out of control. When Isaac first hit by the apple, he started to think what was the cause of the falling? When Walt saw the moving cover of the pot, he started to think whether this mysterious force could be used? When Abraham Ortelius observed the matching shapes of several continents, he started to think could the continents were always moving? 

Just as Richard said in his book that ones' own ideas, theories, "memes" would remind unknown if he died without sharing them. Nevertheless, "if the idea catches on, it can be said to propagate itself, spreading form brain to brain." (Richard) The idea of god, as an example from the book, is an undebatable idea that parasites many brains. When things are not explainable, gods came into existence or one might gone crazy. That was probable why, great scientists like Albert Einstein, Isaac Newton and Nicholas Copernicus all believed in gods mostly during the later period of their life. God exits not because it has evidences, actually no one can claim that he has seen god in person, but because people need it and society needs it. People can find explanation and comfort for injustice phenomenon in really life. Society can use god to rule and paralysis people. That is why god has such a high value of survive.