Showing posts with label Reading 2. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reading 2. Show all posts

2/17/14

Reading 2- Meredith Reed


While Henry Jenkins contends that convergence is a recent phenomenon and specifically targets media, I find that the most fascinating is the lack of privacy an artist has once his/her art is published on the internet. The meaning of the message immediately changes once the art is in the hands of someone with a large political agenda, but audiences with the original image could argue that the artist had an agenda himself.

With the use of appropriation and convergence, any form of media can take a message published for public consumption. One recent use of convergence comes from the Jimmy Kimmel show.

Jimmy Kimmel Stunt

Several news programs took the first half of the program to highlight the dangers of twerking, in order to spark interest in their audience and increase viewership. Gif and memes were made out of this video to highlight the ignorance of  pop culture only to find out it was hoax. While the "Bert is Evil" art project sparked more public controversy, there is a definite push towards lack of privacy and appropriation of messages to fit the agenda-setting messages of popular media today.

Reading 2, Lauren Arnold

After reading Henry Jenkins' "Convergence Culture; Worship @ the Alter of Convergence: A New Paradigm for Understanding Media Change," I realized that the world of media and technology is changing more than I was ever aware. When I think back to even just fifteen years ago, when I was six, the most high technology there was was the cell phone and the flat screen TVs. But even within just one year from then, the technology was changing extremely quickly.

 https://sellorelse.ogilvy.com/2011/12/14/the-changing-consumer-mindset/
(The men in this photograph are literally just talking "social media" symbols, it is almost like they do not have their own voice and ideas anymore. This just goes on to prove the point that the convergence of ideas through different mediums can be an incredible thing, but it can also really take away from the individual's personal identity in their being and ideas. I also see that the man on the right feels silenced in that all he can contribute is a Facebook thumbs up "like" symbol, whereas the other man is having all of the agency with his talking. This can be related to Jenkins' third part of convergence through media that: "everyone will survive if everyone works together" where no one knows how to do this unfortunately. Clearly these two are not working together to explain their ideas.).

I related to this idea of ever changing technology in the part of Jenkins' novel where he states that "consumers are fighting for the right to participate more fully in there culture." This reminded me of all of the different types of iPhones, mp3 players, and chargers that have been coming out even in just the last five years! Similar to what Jenkins' explains, this kind of consistent new media innovation is extremely inspiring but can also be over stimulating. Jenkins explains it that if old consumers (probably relating back to when I was around six) were described as passive, isolated, and silent participants- then new consumers would be described as active, social, and noisy participants. (This can also be related to the image as Facebook is the oldest of the social media in the image).

He also explains that we as consumers, whether old or new, become "forced to buy incompatible appliances." This statement reminds me of the iPhone chargers that keep becoming recreated with new designs year after year. I remember getting my first iPhone three years ago, and even in just that time, we have had two new chargers. I also remember my dad's phone from about five years ago, even though it was the same phone as my mom's, the chargers would not fit- they were different chargers. I did not understand this. And each time we would buy a new Verizon Wireless phone, whether it was the Razr, the standard flip phone, or Chocolate (all discontinued phones)- all of these phones had different chargers. There was rarely ever one universal charger that all of the phones could share together. This was clearly instated for Verizon consumers to continue to purchase new phone charger after new phone charger so that Verizon could receive more money.

2/16/14

Reading 2 - Panpan Deng


 When the writer talks about the convergence culture, the first thing comes to my mind is Duck Dynasty. Even though I have not watch this reality show before, I have seen at least ten people who are about forty wearing Duck Dynasty clothing. It is said in the news that “(Duck Dynasty's) merchandise has generated another $400 million in revenue, about half of which is through Walmart”. I begin to think that may the enormous sale of Duck Dynasty merchandise is called grassroots media. For the reason that every shirt is small but the number is huge just like countless grasses. Also in political area the definition about Grassroots is the bottom of the political pyramid, opposite the "establishment," which controls the top. The top in the political pyramid we can assume is the show itself. I can somehow see the effect grassroots bring to the top. Taking myself as an example, I did not know about Duck Dynasty before their merchandise spread all over Walmart. Now in order to use it as an example in my digital art class, I have to do some research about the show.(I am really not interested in watching it.) In a word, I do agree with Jenkins about the convergence culture:  where old and new media collide, where grassroots and corporate media intersect, where the power of the media producer and the power of the media consumer interact in unpredictable ways.


  “None of us can know everything; each of us knows something; and we can put the pieces together if we pool our resources and combine our skills. ” This notion from the reading make me think about a popular searching engine in China, Renrou Search. Renrou, in English means human flesh search engines or cyber manhunt. Here is the link. I do not think this web is the most effective one because if you really want to search someone by a photo or name, the effort is imaginable. Also this web is free and the other effective ones will charge people. Even using such web, after I typed my name, I found one blog which belongs to me shown as the ninth result. I do not know that information they will get with payment. The converge of internet sometimes can also be a bad thing.

Reading 2 - Frank Hu

  In my honest opinion, convergence culture is nothing new. With the advent of any emerging technology comes speculation and a giving away of the old to new. For example, the invention of typewriters and printing was likely also met with uncertainty. Scribes likely feared for their jobs and machine producers were ecstatic.

 There is only one difference between convergence in its historical context and the media convergence of today. The old form of convergence was around functional positions, physical skills like making a machine or writing words. Convergence, as discussed by Jenkins is around the mental, creative outputs v.s sweat of brow. The internet and technology has allowed convergence to take place on greater heights than it has ever been in the past, but it IS still convergence and comparable to any other event in history where new technology was introduced.

 To put this into context, consider Grumpy Cat.
  He is an online phenomenon known and held dear by millions. What started his rise to fame was an individual who works as a cashier at Target, no one of notable fame or wealth. The point is, in convergence today any individual can have a large impact upon society as a whole due to the ultimately intellectual basis of the outputs. Whereas "back in the day", an individual only had access to a small subset of the population with new outputs like typed papers. The media convergence of today and historic convergence are very similar with one key difference: intellectual content v.s physical content.

Reading 2 - Truc Le

  In Jenkins’ “Convergence Culture”, the author discusses the effects and consequences of the convergence phenomenon. First of all, I agree with Jenkins that convergence is increasing in popularity, and that both companies and consumers will benefit if they cooperate to refine the converged products. In my opinion, one example that can attest this statement is the Korean popular music (K-pop) culture. The K-pop industry is constantly earning more revenues, producing more idol singers/bands as well as fan clubs. Surprisingly, a large proportion of its revenues comes from reality shows in which K-pop idols and their fans have a chance to interact (such as going on mission trips, competing in athletic contests, or going on a date). This convergence between traditional K-pop industry and Korean broadcasting industry ultimately benefit more parties, thus attesting Jenkins’ claim.

K-pop band "Wonder Girls" in traditional concert...
(source)
... and in reality show
(source)
          In addition, according to Jenkins, although old media are changing because of convergence, “Old media are not being displaced. Rather, their functions and status are shifted by the introduction of new technologies.” I also agree with this notion. I thought of the internet as I was reading this idea of Jenkins. Specifically, the internet was first developed as a network for US military agencies to stay in touch and update on intelligence information. As the internet expands, it begins to serve commercial purposes, and after more than three decades, the internet nowadays have a variety of functions from database searching to networking. The internet is not replaced by any other media, but its roles have changed dramatically due to new technologies.

          Ultimately, Jenkins pointed out a troublesome impact of the convergence culture on today’s life: the convergence of contents is paradoxically producing the divergence of hardware. I feel that current technology does not allow us to incorporate many functions to a device and have those functions reaching its best quality at the same time (for example, a phone camera’s picture quality cannot compare to a professional heavy camera’s). I think that this problem has to be resolved through time because it is not in anyone’s power to fix it instantly. Although convergence brought us this problem, it does carry interesting qualities such as allowing the public to participate in the media development. Will this convergence trend result in more problems as it grows? Or will it create new media? I am curious to see where convergence will lead us to.

Reading 2 - Lauren Owensby

I agree with George Gilder in that I see convergence continuing to replace single-form medias. Regardless of whether they wanted to or not, newspapers have had to move online to help shore up their revenues and try their hand at producing video and interactive content. The demolition of mass culture seems like a good thing to me, considering the few things that unite us as a country: war and athletic competitions. It's in the subcultures that we piece together our identities and decide what to stand up for. They hold meaning, capital, power; the more that are created and the more we engage in them, the less important traditional cultural groupings (citizenship, ethnicity, class, gender, age) mean.

Ex. The My Little Pony fandom has subcultures within the fandom

Advertisers are trying to track these subcultures, but it's only through the giants of Facebook and Google that they're starting to approach "how". And despite the condescension it receives, the "black box fallacy" mode of thinking has been successful on one front- web apps. There are few electronic devices in general that are no longer connected to the internet; sprinklers, security systems, all are plugging in so that being "remote" is no longer an obstacle. I agree that different strategies are needed, though. There are more and more "black boxes"- but the main difficulty is cross-platform compatibility. Google is edging it's way into the device market along with Microsoft and Apple, but each platform has very different capabilities, and there's a definite push to standardize programs (like OpenOffice) and file formats. Licensing and profits are what stand in the way, just like the record companies and publishing houses.